Insurance policies exist to safeguard us from life’s unexpected misfortunes. When disaster strikes, whether it’s a serious car accident, a devastating illness, or damage to your home, we rely on our insurers to step up responsibly and promptly meet their obligations. After all, that’s why we diligently pay our premiums month after month. Unfortunately, sometimes insurers fall short—not merely due to oversight, but from a willful disregard of their legal and contractual commitments. This unscrupulous act is what we call insurance bad faith.
At its very core, insurance bad faith occurs when an insurer acts dishonestly, unjustly, or unreasonably fails to uphold its duties toward its policyholders. Good faith—it’s not just a buzzword; it’s a legal obligation implied in every insurance contract across the United States. Insurers must act fairly, honestly, and reasonably when dealing with their customers. Bad faith practices commonly emerge under two categories: first-party claims (between you and your insurer) and third-party claims (such as those involving liability coverage when someone else has filed suit against you).
Understanding how insurance bad faith works can help you spot unfair practices early and protect your legal rights effectively.
If you’re in Bellevue and already need the assistance of a car accident lawyer, contact us today for a free consultation
Recognizing the warning signs of insurance bad faith can empower you to assertively protect yourself. Here are some frequent examples that indicate insurer misconduct:
Unreasonable Denial of Claims
One of the clearest indicators of bad faith arises when insurers wrongfully deny valid claims. Imagine suffering physical harm or a serious loss only to hear your insurer flippantly state your coverage doesn’t apply, without offering an adequate explanation. Such claim denial tactics are unreasonable, frustrating, and unjustifiable under insurance law.
Unjustified Delays in Investigation or Payments
Insurance bad faith claims often arise when insurers excessively delay processing, investigating, or paying claims. Unfair practices may involve repeatedly requesting irrelevant documentation or prolonging investigations without a clear rationale, adding stress and financial pressure onto policyholders.
Misrepresentation of Policy Terms
Sometimes an insurer might twist words or misrepresent policy terms intentionally to reduce or avoid claim payouts. Such manipulation can take many forms, including deceptive explanations of policy coverage, hiding exclusions, or changing terms after a claim has been filed—a phenomenon sometimes called post-claim underwriting.
Failure to Defend Policyholders Appropriately
When an insurance provider fails to adequately defend a covered lawsuit filed against the policyholder, it constitutes a clear policy violation. Your insurer is obligated to protect you legally, and refusals often result in damaging legal and financial repercussions for policyholders.
Lowball Settlement Offers
Ever heard the saying “don’t settle for crumbs when you deserve the whole cake”? Lowball settlements involve unjustifiably low offers made to pressure policyholders into accepting far less than they deserve or are rightfully entitled to. Such unfair settlements certainly qualify as bad faith maneuvers, particularly when liability and damages are evident and clear.
Coercive and Threatening Tactics
Insurers resorting to threats or aggressive tactics—such as intimidating their policyholders into accepting unfavorable settlements or threatening policy cancellations—cross both ethical and legal boundaries. Such coercion is textbook insurer misconduct and can form strong grounds for insurance dispute litigation.
Legal Framework Governing Insurance Bad Faith Claims
Insurance bad faith claims are governed by each state’s specific insurance law, and these can vary significantly from one jurisdiction to another. Some states rely heavily on statutory laws, explicitly laying out insurer obligations. Others lean more on case law set by previous judicial decisions.
For example, in California, bad faith conduct includes wrongful denial of valid claims, unjustified delays in claim processing, misrepresentation of coverage, and refusal to settle clear claims fairly and promptly. Meanwhile, the statutes in states like Florida emphasize good faith obligations explicitly, highlighting the necessity for insurers to act honestly, transparently, and reasonably, especially when liability is certain or clear.
Consequences for Insurers Acting in Bad Faith
Insurance companies engaging in unfair practices may face serious consequences. When a policyholder successfully proves their insurer committed bad faith, courts can require insurers to pay:
Full compensation for benefits owed.
Consequential damages (costs incurred directly because of delayed or improper payments, such as out-of-pocket expenses).
Punitive damages, intended to penalize particularly egregious or malicious insurer misconduct.
Attorney fees and even interest accrued on delayed payouts.
Indeed, courts take insurance bad faith seriously, providing a strong avenue for policyholders to hold companies accountable.
Contact us todayfor a free consultation to see how we can help Washington State residents
Identifying Insurance Bad Faith: Watch for These Warning Signs
Wondering how to discern insurer misconduct early enough to stop it in its tracks? Here are several red flags you shouldn’t ignore:
Unexplained or Excessive Delays: Your insurer constantly drags its feet without any reasonable excuse.
Claim Denial Without Clear Justification: Claims are hastily refused without citing accurate policy terms or logical explanations.
Communication Breakdowns: Consistently ignoring your inquiries or failing to transparently share critical information about your claim.
Excessive Documentation Requests: Demanding endless, irrelevant paperwork just to frustrate or delay.
Misrepresenting Policy Coverage: Deceptively describing or changing coverage details after a claim is filed.
Shoddy Investigations: Inadequate, biased investigations or dismissing valid, credible evidence.
Bullying and Threatening Behavior: Attempts to pressure you by threats such as canceling your coverage or using scare tactics to coerce acceptance of an unfair settlement.
Document any behaviors that signal unfair practices and consider reaching out to an experienced bad faith insurance attorney for guidance.
Proving Insurance Bad Faith—Building Your Case
Successfully proving insurance bad faith requires diligent preparation. Here are critical steps to strengthen your bad faith claim:
Establishing Your Policy Existence and Coverage
You’ll first need evidence confirming the existence of your insurance policy and that the specific claims filed are covered under your policy’s terms.
Documentation of Wrongful Denial or Unfair Actions
Gather clear evidence proving your insurer’s actions were unreasonable—such as evidence of wrongful denial, unnecessary delays, or lowball settlements—indicating unfair insurer misconduct.
Meticulous Record-Keeping of Correspondence
Keep a precise log of all interactions—emails, letters, calls—with your insurer. Such meticulous communication records can unveil patterns of negligence or deliberate dishonesty.
Reviewing Policy Details Carefully
Analyze your insurance policy thoroughly. Identify specific terms, obligations, or coverage that directly support your assertions and highlight instances of wrongful denial or violations of explicit coverage agreements.
Obtaining the Insurer's Claim File
Request your insurer’s internal claim file. This record typically outlines the decision-making process behind processing or denying your claim and may expose unfair or biased supervisory reviews.
Witness and Expert Testimonies
Statements from credible witnesses or insurance industry experts familiar with standards and practices can bolster your case significantly. These impartial perspectives often illuminate whether a reasonable insurer under the same circumstances would act similarly.
Substantiating Monetary and Nonmonetary Damages
Document meticulously how you suffered financial loss or emotional distress due to the insurer’s unfair actions. Evidence of additional expenses incurred because of delayed payments or denied settlements strengthens your claim.
Seeking Skilled Legal Advice Promptly
Enlisting seasoned legal counsel is invaluable for navigating insurance law complexities, interpreting nuanced policy details, and acquiring essential internal insurer documents legally. Your attorney’s expert advocacy is crucial for constructing a persuasive, precise, and legally compelling bad faith argument.
Experiencing insurance bad faith is exasperating and unjust—after all, insurers shouldn’t add further stress when you’re already dealing with life’s difficulties. Understanding precisely what is insurance bad faith, recognizing examples of bad faith insurance practices, and knowing exactly how insurance bad faith works equips you proactively to identify unscrupulous behavior and defend your legal rights aggressively.
At R Martin Law Group, we understand how frustrating this experience can be. Located in Bellevue, Washington, our skilled legal team, led by celebrated personal injury attorney Rich Martin—recognized among the National Top One Percent of personal injury attorneys—can advocate rigorously for you.
Don’t face your insurance dispute alone. If you suspect insurer misconduct or wrongful denial, call us at R Martin Law Group today. We’ll fight hard to protect your rights and secure the fair settlement you rightfully deserve—because you deserve nothing less.
Contact us today for a no-obligation consultation and take the first step towards finding peace of mind.
Call (425) 635-2000 to Discuss Your Case Details. 100% No Win No Fee Guarantee.
